It's 9pm, and you're staring at a pipeline report that doesn't add up. Your sales leader says the leads are junk, and your marketing leader says sales never follows up on them. Both sound sure of themselves, and you've got no way to tell who's right.
Sarah Shepard, StringCan Interactive's COO and my co-author on the Revenue Rewired book, joined me for an episode on a practice we've used with clients for 16 years: posing as a buyer and testing your own revenue journey. You'll come away knowing how to sort a long list of findings so your team acts on them, and how to answer the person who thinks the whole idea feels sneaky.
This post is based on Episode 83 of Revenue Rewired, Secret Shopping Your Sales Process: Find the Revenue Leaks Your Team Can't See. If you'd rather listen than read, find the full episode on Apple Podcasts, YouTube, Spotify, or Amazon. It's worth your time.
I wish I could tell you that secret shopping started as a clever strategy at StringCan. It came from one of our first clients, a few months after we opened, when their head of sales walked me through everything marketing was doing wrong.
Then I met with the marketing lead and heard the exact same speech pointed the other way. Instead of picking a side, we had a team member go through the whole process from marketing through sales as a prospect, and then did the same with a couple of competitors.
Both teams were wrong, at least based on the experience we had. The sales director got defensive and blamed a new hire who hadn't been trained, which may have been true, but it was still what our shopper ran into a week after we'd met.
Sarah was on site with a client whose team was sure they handled calls better than anyone in their industry, so she grabbed the conference room phone and dialed a competitor where one of the employees used to work.
The rep was so good that Sarah hung up and told the room she was sold. The owner was stunned and pointed out that this competitor had a terrible track record with its customers. When she called the client's own line next with the sales team listening, nobody in the room could argue with the contrast.
A great sales call can make a buyer overlook bad reviews. Fresh eyes catch this stuff fastest, so new StringCan hires give feedback on how we do things during their first four weeks, before they know enough to explain away the rough spots.
A full secret shop usually turns up 20 to 50 issues, and that many can stall a team before anything gets fixed. We sort it by two questions: how much revenue is this leaking, and how long will it take to fix?
Retraining how new reps explain your value might take an hour or two. Rebuilding a CRM workflow with 19 steps could take weeks. Here's the order we work through when the list gets long:
When clients rank their own findings, internal politics creep in, and I've seen a ninth priority that should've been first. Pushing a big fix three quarters out because nobody has the bandwidth only keeps the leak running for another nine months.
About one in every ten times, a client or a StringCan team member tells me this feels icky. Sarah's take is that it comes down to intent. If you're doing it to pin blame on a rep or prove a manager wrong, it's unethical because the goal isn't pure.
If you're looking for gaps in a buying experience that keeps changing, you're on solid ground. She's fine with giving staff a heads-up, as long as you note that the results may skew a little, since your weakest performers will struggle to stay on their best behavior for a couple of weeks straight.
My view is simpler. Your competitors are likely shopping you already, and across hundreds of these projects, we've never walked away without learning something worth the awkward feeling.
If you'd like an outside read on how buyers experience you, contact us and we'll talk through where a mystery shop would help first.
Q: What is secret shopping in B2B sales?
A: It's having someone go through your buying process the way a real buyer would, from the first ad through the sales conversation, to find friction your team stopped noticing.
Q: How often should a company run a secret shopper audit?
A: Once every year or two isn't frequent enough, since new hires and process changes keep shifting the experience. A newer client of ours now does it right before each quarterly review meeting.
Q: Can our own team handle secret shopping?
A: You can, and we've coached clients through it, but internal politics tend to skew how issues get prioritized. Get an outside reviewer on your final priorities before you act.
Q: How are AI buyers changing the buyer journey?
A: AI agents now browse sites and even make phone calls for buyers, and what they experience differs from what a person does. Depending on your industry, you may need to test both versions.